[b-hebrew] Yom in Biblical and Rabbinic Texts
peter at qaya.org
Wed Oct 26 11:34:36 EDT 2005
On 26/10/2005 15:57, Bryant J. Williams III wrote:
>Dear Peter, Yigal, et al,
>True, but understanding the word "day" in a non-literal sense also does
>not work - and is arguably already "adding elements that are not in the
>text" and "midrash, but certainly not a literal understanding of the
>text". There is no easy answer.
>The problem as I see it, (sorry, basketball official jargon, :))) ), YOM causes
>us to want to eisegete our interpretation into the text to correspond with what
>our view of regarding the universe and creation-evolution. The word used with
>numbers to indicate a 24-hr period = evening and morning is quite clear. BUT we
>are not at liberty to translate via application. The straight dope is to render
>it as day. In other word, at this point is confusing application with
>interpretation = eisegesis. Beyond that is flat out wrong. The context is quite
>clear about that.
Thank you for the clarification. As a translator, I agree that YOM
should be translated "day" in Genesis 1, although probably not in 2:4.
If I were to interpret this for a congregation etc, I would need to go
into what Yigal calls midrash, but that is the nature of preaching and
For a similar reason Revelation is one of the easiest books in the Bible
to translate - because all of the complex imagery has to be translated
literally, and the interpretation can be left to others.
peter at qaya.org (personal)
peterkirk at qaya.org (work)
More information about the b-hebrew