[b-hebrew] Initial "Beged Kefet" consonants always have a...
VadimCherny at mail.ru
Sat Oct 8 14:58:15 EDT 2005
>>The "word" in the above rule probably means a prosodic word so that in A
>>maqaf B the first letter in B wouldn't have a dagesh.
> It's not a prosodic rule. It's not hard to find examples in Tanach of
> the same prosody with different trope types, and, hence, different
> BEGED KEFET behavior. The Masoretes invented this arbitrary
> inter-word rule (and, actually, for all we know, invented the entire
> BEGED KEFET rule).
The people who painstakingly marked every minutest thing in the Tanakh
invented a rule, huh?
They just wrote down what they actually heard. And, of course, they heard
strengthening (loss of aspiration) after a stop. And, of course, anyone
concerned with distinct pronunciation in singing (cantillation) introduces
stop between the words to avoid concatenation and subsequent loss of first
consonant in a cluster.
natan bakar -> nata nbakar (nata 'bakar) -> natan.bakar
This is the same process as created intra-word dagesh kal:
ni-zcar - ni'car -> niz.car
This makes clear why maqef+vowel eliminates dagesh: consonant clusters
appear, no blurring of the first consonant, nothing to prevent. Since the
first word in maqef constructs loses accent, its final vowel is almost
unaccented, and there is no post-tonic gemination (dagesh hazak), either.
More information about the b-hebrew