[b-hebrew] consonant vowel order of )EHYEH & YAHWEH
VadimCherny at mail.ru
Tue Oct 4 14:41:07 EDT 2005
>> The example shows that unaccented long a can be pronounced as short o.
> No, Vadim, vice versa in your Russian example. In Russian the phoneme "o"
> when it becomes unaccented is pronounced as a short "a" sound, or in fact
> more like English short "u"
Both relations hold. Long o, when losing accent, becames short a.
Long a, when losing accent, becomes short o, as in the example I quoted.
, but in any case indistinguishable from
> unaccented "a". So, if Russian did have any relevance here, it would not
> support your theory. But then I don't accept that it has any relevance,
> for the overall phonological systems of Russian and Hebrew are extremely
Considering that I just showed how the Russian has hatef-kamatz, are they
really so different?
Besides, the Russian example was only illustrative. In the hiphil YHWH,
first vowel is a, and so composite schwa under hey is likely to be
hatef-kamatz, pronounced o in Hebrew.
Less likely, is the composite schwa was hatef-patah, then very possibly the
second a in Yahawah was taken for unaccented o by Europeans, and replaced
More information about the b-hebrew