[b-hebrew] arabic dictionary
abuian at access4less.net
Mon Mar 7 05:39:08 EST 2005
Bearpecs at aol.com wrote:
> I'm thinking that I should have an Arabic-English dictionary to look up
> Semitic cognates. I can sound out the alif-ba but don't really know any grammar.
> I need something with very clear typeface.
> Which would be best for my purposes?
Probably the best in terms of price and simplicity is Wehr. The problem
is, it's not going to give you much information--just a few glosses, no
evidence. It also won't say much about how recent a meaning is, etc. So
although it might help you confirm that the gloss provided in the
cognate evidence of HALOT wasn't a complete misrepresentation, it won't
provide you with much new information. For that, you'd have to get
something much larger and much more expensive, since with Arabic you're
dealing with such a large vocabulary. You might also find it difficult
to get really good lexical resources designed primarily for an English
reader. Finally, I'd advise caution in this area, because just finding
something in an Arabic dictionary is a far cry from knowing much about
how useful it is as a Hebrew cognate. The Arabic lexicon has been
overused in comparative Semitics by some pretty good scholars. The
danger for a novice, who has no feel for the language, no way to check
for words in context, etc., is undoubtedly much greater.
More information about the b-hebrew