peterkirk at qaya.org
Mon Nov 15 10:54:16 EST 2004
On 15/11/2004 15:23, Ken Penner wrote:
>>course, is not Hebrew per se, it's the Latin spelling of the Greek
>>pronunciation of the Aramaic name Beth-Hisda. In Hebrew it
>>would have been
>>"Beth-Hessed" or "Beth Hahessed".
>First, the Greek alpha ending on Semitic words ending in a consonant does
>not always indicate the word is from Aramaic (reflecting the Aramaic
>determined state). Consider Sabbata and Pascha, which are from Hebrew roots
>$BT and PSX; these roots are not otherwise attested in Aramaic (which would
>use NWX for rest). Blass-Debrunner-Funk's Greek grammar says the Alpha is
>added to help pronunciation.
It is worth noting that even in the Masoretic Text the few words which
end with a double consonant (only certain verb forms) are pointed with
sheva under the final consonant as well as under the penultimate one.
This final sheva could have been a silent one, but if so this is an
exception to the rule that two silent shevas do not occur together. More
probably, I would think, the final sheva indicates a short vowel sound
at the end of the word, added because Hebrew speakers were not used to
pronouncing word final consonant clusters. The result would have sounded
like a short a or e, and could well have been transliterated into Greek
>Third, regarding the etymology, Randall Buth suggests five possibilities,
>any of which could result in the Greek Bethesda: Hebrew beth-eshed (house of
>a waterfall) or Hebrew/Aramaic bet-Hesed/Hesda (house of grace) or a Greek
>loanword, bet-estyav (house of pillars) or bet-za'atha (house of the
>movement) or bet-zayta (house of the olive). Note that the (Hebrew) Copper
>Scroll does list a place possibly named BYT )$DTYN; this could be an
>Aramaic name in a Hebrew text.
It is worth noting that the Greek New Testament text from which the name
Bethesda is taken, John 5:2, there is a considerable variety of
spellings. The Nestle-Aland text prefers BHQZAQA (Bethzatha), as in
Sinaiticus. Several MSS have BHQSAIDA (Bethsaida). Many MSS read BHQESDA
(Bethesda) but these do not include the oldest ones. I would surmise
that John actually wrote BHQZAQA, perhaps based on a colloquial
pronunciation of the name, but that this was later corrected to the more
probable and perhaps more accurate BHQESDA.
peter at qaya.org (personal)
peterkirk at qaya.org (work)
More information about the b-hebrew