[b-hebrew] Re: agent or patient in Psa. 33:12?

Jerry Shepherd jerry.shepherd at taylor-edu.ca
Thu May 13 13:11:42 EDT 2004


It seems to me that the greatest problem with trying to trying to
translate this verse with the proposed alternative is that the only way
the alternative can work is by taking what is most likely to be
understood as a verbless clause with accompanying complement of
specification and turning it into two independent clauses: "Blessed is
the nation whose God is Yahweh.  The people chose for an inheritance for
itself."  As mentioned in other responses, you are left without an
object for bachar in the B line, and as well it messes up the intention
of applying ashre to both hagoy and ha'am: "Blessed is the nation whose
God is Yahwey; blessed the nation he chose for an inheritance for
himself." Even though this is poetry, and therefore all kinds of rules
get broken, in this case, almost certainly, if the psalmist had wanted
to specify that the ha'am does the choosing, there would have been an
'asher inserted after ha'am.

 

Jerry

 

Dr. Jerry E. Shepherd

Associate Professor of Old Testament

Taylor Seminary

11525 - 23 Avenue

Edmonton, AB T6J 4T3

CANADA

Office: (780)431-5250

Home: (780)434-1164

Fax: (780)436-9416

Email: Jerry.Shepherd at taylor-edu.ca

Internet: http://www.taylor-edu.ca 

 

 




More information about the b-hebrew mailing list