[b-hebrew] Re: 22nd Psalm & 40th Psalm
kwrandolph at email.com
Thu Nov 27 23:08:18 EST 2003
I hesitated getting involved in this discussion because of its obvious theological overtones. But there are a couple of linguistic notes to mark.
KRH as a verb seems to have the meaning of to provide, to furnish. It does not specify how the provision is made. In the case of providing a well, it is done by digging, though the by digging is left out of texts such as Gen. 26:25, Ex. 21:33. In Pr. 16:27 that which is provided is displeasure. In Ps 40:7 it is ears that are provided. In this I agree with you.
K)R in Ps 22:17 (16 in English) is in the place where one would expect to find a verb, as you mentioned below. As for what it means, there is too little context in Tanakh to give a certain understanding. As the text presently stands, the meaning as a lion does not fit. Are there any clues from cognate languages?
Karl W. Randolph.
----- Original Message -----
From: "Yigal Levin" <leviny1 at mail.biu.ac.il>
> Hi Folks,
> The following points:
> 1. The verb KRH/KRY means "to dig", NOT "to pierce". To pierce one's ear is
> RC(, as in Exod. 21:6.
> 2. In the wider context of Ps. 22, the speaker is surrounded by bad animals:
> bulls, lions (v. 14 [13 in English]), dogs and bad folk in our verse, and
> again dogs, lions and "reemim" (whatever they are) a few verses down. SO
> "like lions" makes perfect sense here.
> 3. However, IF K)RY is "like (a/the) lion", the verb is missing. "my hands
> and feet ARE like lions" doesn't fit the context - I'd expect something like
> "TPSW" - "like a lion they caught my hands and feet". But that's not in the
> text. Which may be why the vorlage of the DDS and the LXX had KRW - to
> supply a verb. But what does "piercing hand and feet" mean IN THIS CONTEXT,
> unless it's about Jesus. Which it's not (at least, "king David" didn't think
> it was...).
> 4. The way I read Ps. 40:7 is, since God created us with ears to hear and to
> understand, He does not want sacrifices. KRYT, "you dug" here does not refer
> to opening up ears that were closed, but to the original creation of ears in
> our bodies.
Sign-up for Ads Free at Mail.com
More information about the b-hebrew