Question: Off topic? More

Moshe Shulman mshulman at
Fri Mar 15 14:28:38 EST 2002

At 03:05 AM 3/15/02 -0500, Randall Buth wrote:
>shalom Moshe,
> >All translations involve compromises and
> >hard decisions, knowing that you are doomed to err because the two
> >languages, Hebrew and English are so different. (BTW this is not the case
> >with Arabic, or other Semitic translations.)
>I would prefer to say "all translations". I am always disappointed with the
>Arabic translations. A related language is still a different language, a
>network of 'spaghetti'. And the culture is different. And history. A
>encodes a culture, a culture is encoded in a language. You cannot truly
>know one without the other.

I understand this. However the difference between English and Hebrew is 
many times greater. I do not know Arabic at all, but I can recognize some 
of the words when I hear them as being the similar to Hebrew.

moshe shulman mshulman at    718-436-7705
Chassidus shiur:                  chassidus-subscribe at
Chassidus discussion list:        chassidus-subscribe at
Outreach Judaism        
ICQ# 52009254    Yahoo/MSN Messaging: mosheshulman

More information about the b-hebrew mailing list