Perfective, Imperfective, and Iterative
emory2oo2 at hotmail.com
Tue May 28 08:46:44 EDT 2002
> 2) The so-called "lexical aspect" is normally not applied to single
>verbs but to verb phrases. The more factors (here there are several words
>and their relationships) that possibly can account for a characteristic,
>the more difficult it is to connect the characteristic with just *one*
Correct me where I am wrong.
I have not found this to be the case. Rather, "lexical aspect"
is ONLY applied to a SINGLE WORD/LEXEME.
Using the verb "run" for example, we can see how +DURATIVITY is
its semantical (uncancellable) lexical aspect, even if we use
it as part of a +TELIC phrase.
To see a verb's semantical lexical aspect, you have to consider it
in a vacuum, all by itself with no other grammatical intrusions.
I use the word "aspect" to denote INHERENT PROPERTIES. (For
example, the words you list DURATIVITY, TELIC, DYNAMICITY, STATE
are what I call Lexical Aspect.)
"Run" regardless of context, morphological features, modifiers, etc.,
will always denote a +DURATIVE aspect.
"I run." (Here, "run" is +DURATIVE.)
"I run a lap now and then." (Here, "run" remains +Durative,
but the PHRASE "run a lap" is +TELIC. But overall, you have the sense
of "I run for the duration of a lap now and then.")
One can not change "run" into a -DURATIVE action.
Now, when "run" is used with an imperfective FORM, perfective FORM,
or a stative FORM, you will have the SAME +DURATIVITY of the verb,
but WHERE the author/writer wants to FOCUS the readers' attention
is now brought to bear. These FORMS I call Grammatical Aspect.
Imperfective forms are Present and Imperfect.
Perfective forms are Aorist, Future, and Pluperfect.
Stative form is the Perfect.
So that, we might have this:
1. run plus imperfective: focus on this action IN PROGRESS
2. run plus perfective: focus on this action AS A WHOLE, IN SUMMARY
3. run plus stative: focus on the AFTERMATH/RESULTS of this action
Am I right in thinking that you disagree with Olsen on the issue
of Lexical Aspect?
Grammatically, what is your definition of ASPECT?
And what terms do you use to denote what I am calling:
Get your FREE download of MSN Explorer at http://explorer.msn.com/intl.asp.
More information about the B-Greek