What is _not_ generally well-known is that despite "whatever date" one wants
for the Exodus, there are archaeological anomalies that refuse to go away-
that is to say one can find places that either were not yet in existence or
were abandoned for ANY proposal, Early Bronze through Iron Ages. When faced
with these archaeological anomalies the usual response by the proposer is to
"dismiss the anomalies" by claiming the sites must be incorrectly
identified, or there is a "wrong" Egyptian chronology being used which needs
"fixing" to make the archaeological evidence "align" with the Biblical
chronology and account.
Professor William H. Stiebing Jr. has written a book on ALL the anomalies
for ANY given date, and ALL who are interested in this subject -"the dating
of the Exodus"- ought to read his book before accepting anybody's proposal
for an Exodus date (William H. Stiebing Jr. _Out of the Desert ? Archaeology
and the Exodus/Conquest Narratives_. Prometheus Books. Amherst, New York.
1989. paperback [go to www.prometheusbooks.com to order the book;
alternately, you may be able to obtain it via Inter-Library Loan through
your local library])
He sums up the problem very succinctly :
"Almost all of the sites mentioned in the biblical Conquest stories were
settled in the Iron Age, while many were often not occupied in earlier
periods. What might this mean ? Perhaps the biblical accounts say more about
when the stories began to take shape than they do about the Conquest itself.
There does not seem to be a point in the archaeological sequence in
Palestine where the physical evidence revealed by the spade closely matches
the biblical Exodus and Conquest narratives. Whether the Exodus and Conquest
are placed at the end of Early Bronze III or Middle Bronze II, or in the
Iron Age I, there are still serious discrepancies, just as there are with
the more common Late Bronze Age placements for these events." (pp.146/148)
Regards, Walter
Walter Reinhold Warttig Mattfeld y de la Torre, M.A. Ed.
mattfeld12 AT charter.net
www.bibleorigins.net
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.