Skip to Content.
Sympa Menu

cc-licenses - Re: CC licenses and documentary films

cc-licenses AT lists.ibiblio.org

Subject: Development of Creative Commons licenses

List archive

Chronological Thread  
  • From: "Branko Collin" <collin AT xs4all.nl>
  • To: <cc-licenses AT lists.ibiblio.org>
  • Subject: Re: CC licenses and documentary films
  • Date: Tue, 30 Nov 2004 15:11:30 +0100

On 29 Nov 2004, at 10:55, Nicholas Bergson-Shilcock wrote:

> I'm sure this question has already been asked and answered, but I
> haven't yet found it in your archives. I would appreciate any guidance
> you can offer on this topic.
>
> What happens when somebody wants to attach a CC license to a
> documentary film that includes "fair use" snippets of copyrighted
> work? The documentary in question includes both slightly longer
> segments (which, although almost certainly fair use, the documentary
> maker paid for) and short pieces that are assumed to be such a small
> percentage of the original work that it is fair use to include them in
> the documentary.
>
> I know how subjective fair use decisions are, so I fear that I already
> know the answer, but: Is it permissible to use a CC license in this
> context?

(IANAL, and know little of US law)

AFAIK, fair use is a legal defense, not a right. So it would seem
that it cannot collide with copyrights and licenses.

Although in principle the idea of identifying bits 'owned' by others
on the credit role seems sensible, there are two arguments that may
speak against it.

One is that, since fair use is a defense after the fact of
infringement, mentioning fairly used bits in the film is an admission
of infringement. Somehow, that doesn't seem wise.

The second is that a list might convey the suggestion that the list
is exhaustive. In a documentary, that is hardly going to be the case.
Every piece of clothing, every building, every painting wall that the
eye of the camera quickly passes by may be copyrighted.

In the end, it is up the user of your work to know the law. Would it
be reasonable to expect a documentary in which not a single
copyrighted item appears?

--
branko collin
collin AT xs4all.nl




Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.

Top of Page