Skip to Content.
Sympa Menu

b-hebrew - [b-hebrew] Traveling "By Stages"

b-hebrew AT lists.ibiblio.org

Subject: Biblical Hebrew Forum

List archive

Chronological Thread  
  • From: JimStinehart AT aol.com
  • To: b-hebrew AT lists.ibiblio.org
  • Subject: [b-hebrew] Traveling "By Stages"
  • Date: Tue, 5 Apr 2011 10:31:03 EDT


Traveling “By Stages”

In Genesis, the word LMS(YW only appears at Genesis 13: 3. It means “by
stages” [Wenham, “Genesis 1-15” (1987), at p. 296], and is often [though not
always] translated as “by stages”. The same basic idea is conveyed in
another manner at Genesis 12: 9, where we see WYS(…WNSW(. Wenham at p. 267
explains the grammatical construction here as “Waw consec + 3 masc sg impf
NS(.”
Robert Alter, “Genesis” (1996) also gets excited about this grammatical
construction at Genesis 12: 9, and comments at p. 51: “The verb for ‘
journey’ in verse 9 also derives from another term for pulling up of tent
stakes,
and the progressive form in which it is cast is a precise indication of
movement through successive encampments.” Alter uses the phrase “by stages”
to translate Genesis 12: 9: “And Abram journeyed onward by stages to the
Negeb.”

At p. 281, the earlier part of Wenham’s explanation of this verse is O.K.,
but then he errs grievously in misrepresenting what Genesis 12: 9 says: “‘
Went on traveling toward the Negev’ summarizes several stages in Abram’s
journey southward. The grammatical construction (see Notes [quoted above])
suggests a series of encampments. The root NS( is particularly common in
descriptions of Israel’s wilderness wanderings (e.g. Num 33), and it may not
be
coincidental that the term is introduced when Abram reaches the area closely
associated with them, viz., ‘the Negeb’.”

No, no, no! Genesis 12: 9 does n-o-t say that! Genesis 12: 9 clearly
and unequivocally says that the time and place when Abram and Lot travel “by
stages” is when Abraham and Lot are between Bethel and Negev, and have not
yet reached the Negev, but rather are traveling “toward” the Negev. It is
n-o-t after Abram “reaches” the Negev that Abram journeys “by stages”. A
thousand times No! Rather, it is when Abram and Lot are b-e-t-w-e-e-n
Bethel and the Negeb that they travel “by stages”.

The exact term “by stages” is used in the identical locale at Genesis 13:
3: “And he went on by stages from the Negeb up to Bethel….” [Alter
translation] Notice that the o-n-l-y time in the entirety of the
Patriarchal
narratives when anyone is said to travel “by stages” is precisely when Abram
and Lot are b-e-t-w-e-e-n the Negev and Bethel [not when anyone is i-n
the Negev]. Though different wording is used at Genesis 12: 9 and Genesis
13: 3, both verses insist that when Abram and Lot are b-e-t-w-e-e-n Bethel
and the Negev [not in the Negev], they travel “by stages”.

What’s going on here? What route did Abram and Lot take in traveling
between the Negev and Bethel in the context of going to and from Egypt, with
some
animals going with Abram to Egypt, and many animals coming back with Abram
from Egypt?

If we focus on the words (i) LMS(YW at Genesis 13: 3, and (ii) WYS(…WNSW(
at Genesis 12: 9, we can figure out the exact route that Abram and Lot took
between Bethel and the Negev in traveling to and from Egypt. The huge payoff
in paying close attention to the Hebrew text here is that we will find out,
for the first time, what Lot felt that Lot was giving up in choosing to
travel east of Bethel when Lot and Abram split up at Bethel. What life was
there to be lived in the route that Abram and Lot had taken between the Negev
and Bethel? Didn’t Lot give up that lifestyle awfully quickly, and soon was
living the soft life in Sodom with a roofbeam over his head? On the other
hand, why does Abraham seem so content in living in the very place where
Abram and Lot have traveled between the Negev and Bethel, to the extent that
one
even worries a bit that Abraham might have given up on the divine promise
of a-l-l of Canaan, if Abraham could continue living in harmony there
[where he and Lot had recently traveled together “by stages”] and have a son
by
Sarah [or maybe, perish the thought, even content himself with a son on Sarah
’s behalf by Hagar]? YHWH actually seems to have to push Abraham a bit on
both fronts, insisting that Abraham’s proper heir will be borne by Sarah
[despite Abraham championing Ishmael’s cause at Genesis 17: 18], and also
insisting that Abraham get off his duff and start sojourning in GRR. It is
critically important to note that (i) Abraham perfects his claim to a-l-l
of
Canaan, having moved to GRR, at the same time as (ii) Lot forfeits his claim
to any part of Canaan, with Lot being unceremoniously [but properly] reduced
to living in a cave, and (iii) Sarah gets pregnant with Isaac. All three of
those events happen at virtually the same time, and that’s no coincidence.
YHWH in effect won’t let Abraham have a son by Sarah until Abraham moves to
GRR, and Abraham can’t move to GRR until Lot’s provisional claims to part
of Canaan are out of the way, so all of these pending issues are going to be
resolved in one fell swoop, all at the same time: Lot begins living in a
cave, Abraham moves to GRR [thereby perfecting his claim to all of Canaan, as
divinely promised and insisted upon], and Sarah gets pregnant with Isaac.
Game, set, match.

But we cannot understand the story unless we start from the beginning, and
focus on the words LMS(YW at Genesis 13: 3 and WYS(…WNSW( at Genesis 12: 9.
Where exactly were Abraham and Lot when they were traveling “by stages”?
Why does Abraham love the lifestyle there, seeming to consider it perfect in
all ways [with Abraham perhaps being a bit too comfortable there, from YHWH’
s perspective], whereas Lot effectively says “good riddance” to that
lifestyle, and without ever looking back confidently proceeds east from
Bethel?
The words LMS(YW and WYS(…WNSW( are telling us what route Abram and Lot took
between Bethel and the Negev, if we take the exact wording of the Hebrew
text seriously, and are willing to question/jettison the traditional and
scholarly view.

Jim Stinehart
Evanston, Illinois



  • [b-hebrew] Traveling "By Stages", JimStinehart, 04/05/2011

Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.

Top of Page