Skip to Content.
Sympa Menu

b-hebrew - Re: Mt.Sinai in Arabia?

b-hebrew AT lists.ibiblio.org

Subject: Biblical Hebrew Forum

List archive

Chronological Thread  
  • From: Polycarp66 AT aol.com
  • To: tmcos AT hotmail.com, b-hebrew AT franklin.oit.unc.edu
  • Subject: Re: Mt.Sinai in Arabia?
  • Date: Thu, 20 Apr 2000 17:36:55 EDT


In a message dated 4/20/2000 12:40:22 PM Central Standard Time,
tmcos AT hotmail.com writes:

<< I know this may be unrelated but I was wondering if any of you have heard
about a book wriiten by a Larry Williams arguing that the biblical Mt.Sinai
is not in the Sinai Peninsula but rather in Saudi Arabia. Paul mentions
Mt.Sinai being "in Arabia" in Gal 4:25. I know of no serious scholar that
has argued this. This may be just hype. Any thoughts? Thank you.
>>

I think we probably tend to impose our modern concept of what constitutes
Arabia on this. Here is a section from the _Anchor Bible Dictionary_ , s.v.
"Arabia."



ARABIA (PLACE) [Heb >(a:RaB]. ARABIAN. The OT has no true geographical place
name “Arabia,” the collective noun >aáraµb (“Arabs”) being used to
designate the region; the geographical term “Arabia” appears only in Greek
texts. Arabs are also sometimes referred to in the OT as beáneÆ qedem “people
[literally “sons”] of the East” (e.g., Judg 6:3, 1 Kgs 4:30) and their
region as <eres\ qedem, “land of the East,” or simply qedem, “East” (so Gen
25:6, Isa 2:6).

A. History and Geography
The origin of the Arabs is debated; the conventional view is that they
originated in the central or S part of the Arabian peninsula (e.g.,
Montgomery 1934, Hitti 1970). The inclusion of the S part of the peninsula in
the designation “Arabia” is not, however, attested until Roman times, nor do
people identified as “Arabs” appear in ancient texts as inhabitants of the S
region until the same period (Eph>al 1982:8); prior to that time the S region
was known by the names of the various kingdoms that inhabited it, such as
Saba, Qataban, and Hadhramaut. Considerable evidence favors the theory that
the Arabs first appeared on the N, W, and E edges of the Syrian desert, with
an extension into the Negev, the Sinai peninsula, and the N part of the Hejaz
(the NW coast and mountain range of the Arabian peninsula).
Egyptian texts as early as the 3d millennium b.c. refer to inhabitants of the
S Levant as “sand-dwellers,” a term that originally must have alluded to
nomads, although even at that early date it also applied to sedentary
Levantine peoples. The homeland of these Asiatics was sometimes designated,
as in the Egyptian story of Sinuhe which originated in the 20th century b.c.,
by the Semitic word qedem. Archaeological investigations have shown that
nomads were much in evidence in Syro-Palestinian life during the period
2200–1900 b.c., following the collapse of the EB cultures, but partially
withdrew to the S and E desert regions during the subsequent centuries of
ascendancy of the Canaanite city-states. The tendency of nomads to press into
Palestine and W Transjordan as the Canaanite culture began to disintegrate
during the latter part of the 1st millennium b.c. was impeded by the
establishment of Edom, Moab, Israel, and other fledgling kingdoms. During
much of the 1st millennium b.c. Arabs moved about on the fringes of the
settled regions, not only providing the sedentary peoples with sheep, goats,
camels, asses, and animal by-products such as skins and wool, but also
serving as itinerant merchants trading in spices, dates, embroidery, incense,
iron, copper, gold, precious stones, pearls, and other commodities, some of
which originated in distant places (see Gen 2:11, 1 Kgs 10:2, Ezek 27:21–22).
Arabs were also active in the extreme S part of Palestine and Transjordan
during the OT period. Nomadic groups, often called by tribal names rather
than the generic term “Arab,” had long moved about in the W part of the
Negeb between Judah and the “Brook of Egypt” (Wadi el->Arish, the
traditional border between Palestine and Egypt) and in the rugged terrain E
toward Edom and Midian. The Midianites, who were related to, if not identical
with, the biblical Ishmaelites, were of Arab stock, and engaged in
caravaneering. The biblical story of Joseph describes a Midianite caravan on
its way from Gilead in the Transjordanian highlands to Egypt, passing through
the vicinity of Dothan in N Palestine (Gen 37:25–28). The traders carried
with them stock items of resin, balm, and myrrh, and also trafficked in
slaves. Some Arab tribes probably made their living, as they did at later
times in history, by preying upon such caravans, or by raiding villages or
the encampments of other Arabs.
The earliest known appearance of the word “Arab” in extrabiblical texts is
in an Assyrian record from the time of Shalmaneser III which states that an
Arab leader named Gindibu<, who probably had his home on the SW edge of the
Syrian desert, went with troops and 1000 camels to participate in a military
coalition against the Assyrians that culminated in the battle of Qarqar in
853 b.c. Arabs appear frequently in the records of a number of later Assyrian
monarchs, from Tiglath-pileser III through Ashurbanipal (745–627 b.c.),
sometimes as allies and sometimes as the vanquished. Tiglath-pileser’s annals
identify various Arab tribes or leaders that were nominally integrated into
the Assyrian empire. Under Sargon II, some Arabs were resettled in Palestine
and elsewhere, either voluntarily or otherwise (see Eph>al 1982: 105–8).
Arabs also appear sporadically in the records of the subsequent
Neo-Babylonian and Persian empires. None of the Near Eastern empires could,
however, effectively control these nomads or their territories permanently;
at most they could make incursions into the inhospitable desert regions, and
usually had to content themselves with striking bargains with the Bedouin
leaders to achieve their main goal, that of keeping commercial routes open.
See BEDOUIN AND BEDOUIN STATES.
During the Greco-Roman period, the Arabs became much better known than
previously. Geographers began to make rudimentary distinctions among the
regions inhabited by Arabs, referring to the North Arabian region as “Arabia
Deserta” and the SW coast of the Arabian peninsula as “Arabia Felix.”
Damascus was generally regarded as standing at the NW corner of Arabia
Deserta (cf. Jdt 2:25). A third region, Arabia Petraea, emerged in Edom as
one group of Arabs, the Nabataeans, rose to prominence during the 3d–1st
centuries b.c. Transforming tribal leadership into kingship and their nomadic
way of life into a sedentary existence, the Nabataeans gradually increased
their cultural sphere N and W during this time, becoming prosperous through
trade. They vigorously and creatively adapted Hellenistic-Roman culture to
their indigenous traditions, particularly in their capital city of Petra. By
the early 1st century a.d., at its zenith, the kingdom of Nabatea dominated a
large part of Transjordan and the Negev (see Glueck 1959 and 1970, Bowersock
1983, and Negev 1986). See also NABATEANS.
The Romans, who had actively entered the governance of the Levant with
Pompey’s conquest of Syria and Palestine in 64–63 b.c., maintained the
Nabataeans as a client state within the larger geographical region they
called “Arabia” (comprising portions of Transjordan, S Syria, the Negev, and
the NW Arabian peninsula) for well over a century, but in a.d. 106 annexed a
large part of the Nabatean kingdom as a Roman province. Subsequently,
attempting to prevent the still populous non-Nabatean Arab groups situated
farther to the E and S from encroaching upon the boundaries of the empire,
the Romans established a series of military posts in Transjordan (see
Bowersock 1983 and Parker 1986), but these only partially achieved their
purpose and after several centuries were abandoned; ultimately the Romans
proved to have little more success than previous empires in controlling the
Arabs. During the 4th–6th centuries a.d. the Arabs had considerable contact
with the Byzantine world, but it was only when Islam emerged in the 7th
century a.d. that they moved to the forefront of Near Eastern history.

Freedman, David Noel, ed., The Anchor Bible Dictionary, (New York: Doubleday)
1997, 1992.

gfsomsel




Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.

Top of Page