[cc-community] sound and video CC-ND

yul01 at riseup.net yul01 at riseup.net
Tue Apr 3 19:06:22 EDT 2012


Hey. I have some problems to get a idea to improve the CC-ND license.
I dont find discussion area on the wiki and it is difficult to communicate
effectively in a mailing list.

I would greatly appreciate those who can read to get my idea to be
considered and discussed.
It is this:

My experience with the interpretation of the creative commons license
no-derivative-works is ambiguous in some cases.
The complicated case is deciding whether you can make a video from cc
audio-nd.

A video is a movie clip with sound? No.
(Cinema was mute when born)
A video may or may not have sound.
Like a video may or may not have an smell associated.

Therefore, a video are images in movement. Nothing more.

If audio with cc-nd is not modified and I get to dance at the same time.
.. Am I making a derivative work? No.

If audio with cc-nd is not modified and I show a picture at the same
time... Derivative work? No.
Audio is not changing.
Audio and video are distinct and separate.

Another example:
If I have a photo with cc-nd license and i play music .. Am I changing the
picture? No.
Am I making a derivative work? No.

So, my proposal is that any sound with cc-nd license can be used in a
video if the sound is not modified.

If not, all pictures or sounds with CC-ND can't be accompanied by other
images or sounds as in any website.

Sorry for my english.
I hope be useful.
Thanks for all.

yul01.



More information about the cc-community mailing list