[b-hebrew] b-hebrew Uncancellable meaning and Hebrew verbs
Rolf Furuli
furuli at online.no
Sat Jun 27 17:11:50 EDT 2009
Dear Stephen,
>Hi Rolf,
>
>Thank you for outlining your linguistic approach to the analysis of
>WAYYIQTOL. I have a question: Does your approach assume that if
>WAYYIQTOL is ever a past tense, then it must always be a past tense?
No, i do not believe that WAYYIQTOL is ever past tense (past
grammaticalization of locations in time)..
>
>The reason I ask is because of something you asserted about the
>English form "went" (on 23/6 - yes, I'm a way behind):
>
><snip>
>The form "went" has an intrinsic past reference that is not caused
>by the context. There may be exceptions, but again, they can be
>explained as exceptions.
>...
>3) Liz went home.
></snip>
>
>This is not correct. In some contexts the form "went" is modal, for example:
>
>1) If you went to Australia, you would find some of their English
>dialects very difficult to understand.
>
>In this type of construction, the temporal reference that the "went"
>form definitely cannot have is past; if it has temporal reference,
>it is probably future. However, nobody would deny, on the basis of
>this, that "went" is past tense in your example, Liz went home.
>
>Two conclusions: (1) the presence or absence of tense is not
>inextricably tied to a verb form, and (2) the "semantic value" of a
>verb form must take into account wider contextual considerations (or
>better, wider constructional considerations).
I do not follow your reasoning, particularly because you have to
define the deictic center.
>
>Does this fit with your methodology? The reason it seems important
>is that the "went" form in English would similarly have past
>reference the vast majority of the time, but with present and/or
>future exceptions. (I apologise that I cannot check myself whether
>this has any relevance to your dissertation, but I do not have
>access to it presently.)
Sorry, but I do not understand how this has any bearing on Hebrew.
>
>Regards,
>Stephen Shead
>Centro de Estudios Pastorales
>Santiago, Chile
Best regards,
Rolf Furuli
University of Oslo
More information about the b-hebrew
mailing list