| RECOMMENDED | ||
![]() |
Cascadian Farms Premium Organic Sweet Cherries These large, glossy, dark cherries were consistent in both size and appearance—and they tasted as good as they looked, with tasters describing them as “sweet, ripe, and fruity.” Baked in pie, these cherries maintained their texture better than other brands and yielded “pleasantly sweet” cherry flavor. | $3.50 for 10 ounces |
| NOT RECOMMENDED | ||
![]() |
Dole Dark Sweet Cherries Though labeled “dark sweet,” these cherries were bright red, small, and less ripe-looking and sweet than we’d prefer. Above all, the inconsistency in quality from batch to batch was this brand’s fatal flaw. | $4.49 for 12 ounces |
| NOT RECOMMENDED | ||
![]() |
Tree of Life Organic Dark Sweet Cherries Each bag of these cherries contained a selection of random colors and sizes—even the occasional pit. Besides harsh sour notes identified by some tasters, the fruit generally lacked deep cherry flavor, and its mushiness only got worse in a pie. | |
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.