Del you may be lighting a brushfire here - in the seedling vs. clonal debate - just this morning I went with a
bow saw at a black walnut seedling here borne of the Elmer Myers Black Walnut strain.
Observing the extremely straight and exceptionally vigorous growth I hesitated with the bow saw. I can see
this walnut hitting 20' by August, from the 12' it is now.
I do think we oversell clonal varieties and clonal rootstocks too much. There are distinct disadvantages to
the clonal approach....and not enough growing from seed.
I don't know what to do about the seedling walnut. Obviously it'll make a decent saw log in just 10 years vs.
the typical 20. I've never seen such vigor. And how-ever can I propagate it if it proves of value for either
timber or for nuts? Root cuttings? Is it possible to obtain Black Walnut trees from root cuttings?
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.