...In other words, anyone who disagrees with you or tries to offer any evidence of any other position, whether "a christian or a martian", is partisan and ought to be denied the right to put forward that evidence. Tory, I more or less agree with you on this issue, but I am embarrassed to agree with someone taking the attitude you do. Instead, please let them offer their evidence, and then give your counter-arguments which, if they are as strong as you claim, should settle the matter.
HH: How is it that a Christian comment is partisan, but the JPS study
Bible is non-partisan? How is JPS non-partisan?
The JPS footnote is nonpartisan because it does not attempt to restrict the meaning of almah to a physical virgin, as you do constantly. Any comment, be it from a christian or a martian, which attempts to narrow the definition in such a way that physical virginity is "generally to be assumed" is partisan.
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.