...
I've only watched this debate from the sidelines, but it often
appears to me that the two sides (Rolf in one corner, everyone
else in the other) are often talking past each other. One only
needs to look at the many posts back and forth about things which
are ``uncancellable''. It seems to me that when Rolf says to someone
that they doesn't understand what he's talking about that they ought to
think that he might be right in his assertion that they don't
understand and make a renewed effort or greater effort to get
to grips with what is actually being claimed. Often this doesn't
appear to be the case. ...
...
David:-
OK, I'll drop the term in preference for your own "uncancellable
intrinsic meaning". (I still think that this equates to "uncancellable
semantics", but if you don't think so I'll stick to the longer version
"uncancellable intrinsic meaning".)
Just looking at it, David did not say ``Ah ha! Now I get it.'' ...
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.