...
I hate to think that b-hebrew would be a place where the members will make a Ph.D. defend his dissertation in detail. Quite simply, we will attract very few scholars to the list if they must. Any scholars the list does attract will only lurk if the membership will treat the forum like a fox hunt.
To those who say a scholar becomes "open game" as soon as he publishes, so he needs to take the heat or get out of the kitchen: I say, true, but the academic will choose his kitchen, and it won't likely be the b-hebrew e-mail forum. A scholar doesn't need b-hebrew to make his point or his reputation. On the other hand, without the real scholars, the quality of the list decreases for everyone.If a particular scholar, if by that you mean anyone with a PhD in Hebrew, chooses to use this list as a forum to promote their own opinions, they should expect to be questioned about those opinions. If they want to be questioned sparingly, surely they should promote their views sparingly. I don't see why possession of a PhD entitles someone to protection from discussion on this list. Maybe if they were really a well known scholar, published in a recognised (not more or less self-published) book, they would deserve some extra respect. But, if they chose to promote their theories on this list, they should still expect hard questioning.
Yes, I have had long discussions with Rolf over the years, but I think we carried on in a friendly manner, and I tried to keep our exchanges limited to two or three on a topic. I personally don't want to force a Ph.D. Hebraist into writing, "I don't want to continue this discussion any more." That embarrasses him because it seems like a dodge to a membership of about 900 people. Why would any of us want to do that to someone? Do we suppose the professional scholar's grapes are sour?Well, it should be clear to you why I am not concerned about embarrassing Rolf. But it is a dodge. I don't expect him to answer every point, but several times I have identified fundamental flaws in his arguments and he responds by ignoring me. Am I expected to back down and allow other list members to be led astray by his non sequiturs?
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.