From: "walter mattfeld" <mattfeld12 AT charter.net>
To: <b-hebrew AT lists.ibiblio.org>
Subject: [b-hebrew] Language skills
Date: Sun, 4 Sep 2005 09:09:46 -0400
JCP wrote:
"This is something, that as an EFL teacher, I can confirm from firsthand
experience. My worst students
by far were the accademic grammar basher types, who could typically ace an
exam paper but couldn't order a
cup of coffe in a cafe' if their life depended on it.
My best students were typically olympic athletes that had never studied the
language from a grammatical
point of view. When faced with a written exam they would typically make
enormous errors but while speaking
they would not make such errors as they spoke by instinct and had the
ability to not only make themselves
understood but to use idioms and slangy sayings in correct contexts."
James above comment brought back to mind my Sophmore year enrollment in a
1st year Spanish class in High School in Seguin, Texas (1958). I noted on my
first day in class that a number of Mexican students had enrolled and I
thought to myself, these guys already speak and think in Spanish fluently
and this will be one easy course for them to "ace." You can imagine my
surprise to learn later, that although they could speak Spanish better than
the instructor, they were "flunking" the class because they could care less
about memorizing for tests the grammar formalities of conjugations, tenses,
prepositions, etc. So, the "Anglos" who struggled with the pronounciation of
Spanish "aced" the grammar tests and passed the class and _still stumbled_
over the speaking of the language, while the real masters of the language
flunked because they could care less about tests.
Regards, Walter
[b-hebrew] Language skills,
walter mattfeld, 09/04/2005