Skip to Content.
Please activate JavaScript in your web browser
List archive
RE: Ps 102 "you are he"
Chronological
Thread
<
Chronological
>
<
Thread
>
From
: "Bill Ross" <BillRoss AT norisksoftware.com>
To
: "'George Athas'" <gathas AT hotkey.net.au>, "'Biblical Hebrew'" <b-hebrew AT franklin.oit.unc.edu>
Subject
: RE: Ps 102 "you are he"
Date
: Sun, 4 Aug 2002 09:33:29 -0500
<George>
>
>Hebrew usually has it in the attributive position also, but you may
well have a substantive use in Ps 102.
<Bill>
Many thanks to all who have supplied helpful feedback on this issue.
George, am I understanding you correctly that these are the possibile
readings raised:
"you are the identical one [as I am]" [attributive, referring to
sameness of identity]
"you are the identical way [as I am]" [attributive, referring to
sameness of an attribute]
"you are the person in question" [substantive, referring to identity]
"you are unchanged" [attributive, with an unusual, but legit reading]
If you had to translate this verse, how would you do it?
Bill Ross
Re: Ps 102 "you are he"
,
George Athas, 08/01/2002
<Possible follow-up(s)>
Re: Ps 102 "you are he"
,
David Stabnow, 08/01/2002
Re: Ps 102 "you are he"
,
George Athas, 08/04/2002
RE: Ps 102 "you are he"
,
Bill Ross, 08/04/2002
Archive powered by
MHonArc 2.6.24
.