formoria at carolina.rr.com
Tue Jun 15 16:07:19 EDT 2004
On Tuesday, June 15, 2004, at 01:52 PM, Dave Washburn wrote:
> Perhaps what we need in such cases is a better definition of "science."
"Amen", brother, if I may be allowed the misapplication of
It would seem that the definition of science has become a debate for
> On Tuesday 15 June 2004 03:47, Peter Kirk wrote:
>> On 14/06/2004 22:19, Karl Randolph wrote:
>>> Dear Peter:
>>> Now that you bring in science……
>>> This is not a claim that ”creation science“ is science. It is not
>>> for the same reasons evolution is not science.
>> I agree with you, more or less. Certainly evolution in terms of
>> mechanisms is no more scientific than creationism because both are
>> on unfalsifiable speculation.
>>> The reason I objected to ”proto-Semitic“ language, especially as a
>>> yardstick to evaluate Biblical Hebrew, is because it, like evolution,
>>> based on inobservable presuppositions that may or may not be true. I
>>> would prefer to stay with that which can be observed, in this case,
>>> Biblical Hebrew language recorded in Tanakh and what few other
>>> in Biblical Hebrew that we have found.
>> I hadn't mentioned proto-Semitic for some time, but you have
>> my mention of it just posted. Well, there are a large number of words
>> and grammatical structures which are more or less common between many
>> modern and recorded ancient Semitic languages. These are similar to the
>> large number of words and structures in common between e.g. Romance
>> languages which can be traced back to a known ancestor, Latin. It is a
>> reasonable speculation, although formally unprovable I agree, that the
>> common Semitic vocabulary and grammar derive from an original common
>> Semitic language, which is probably lost (although I suppose one could
>> try to argue that proto-Semitic is Akkadian, the oldest recorded
>> language). To go further into determining the exact shape of that
>> proto-language may be speculative, but that is not actually my point.
> Dave Washburn
> Learning about Christianity from a non-Christian
> is like getting a kiss over the telephone.
> b-hebrew mailing list
> b-hebrew at lists.ibiblio.org
More information about the b-hebrew