[permaculture] House May Block Food Safety Bill Over Senate Error : Roll Call
Lawrence F. London, Jr.
lflj at bellsouth.net
Wed Dec 1 23:46:34 EST 2010
House May Block Food Safety Bill Over Senate Error
* By John Stanton
* Roll Call Staff
* Nov. 30, 2010, 10:09 p.m.
A food safety bill that has burned up precious days of the Senate’s lame-duck session appears headed back to the chamber
because Democrats violated a constitutional provision requiring that tax provisions originate in the House.
By pre-empting the House’s tax-writing authority, Senate Democrats appear to have touched off a power struggle with
members of their own party in the House. The Senate passed the bill Tuesday, sending it to the House, but House
Democrats are expected to use a procedure known as “blue slipping” to block the bill, according to House and Senate GOP
The debacle could prove to be a major embarrassment for Senate Democrats, who sought Tuesday to make the relatively
unknown bill a major political issue by sending out numerous news releases trumpeting its passage.
Section 107 of the bill includes a set of fees that are classified as revenue raisers, which are technically taxes under
the Constitution. According to a House GOP leadership aide, that section has ruffled the feathers of Ways and Means
Committee Democrats, who are expected to use the blue slip process to block completion of the bill.
“We understand there is a blue slip problem, and we expect the House to assert its rights under the Constitution to be
the place where revenue bills begin,” the GOP aide said.
The blue slip could lead to one of two likely outcomes. Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) could simply drop the
issue and let the next session of Congress start from scratch, a strategy that would allow him time in the lame-duck
session to tackle other last-minute priorities, such as the expiring 2001 and 2003 tax cuts, a long-term continuing
resolution, an immigration bill and a repeal of the military’s ban on openly gay service members.
Or he could try to force the issue in the Senate after the House passes a new version of the bill. But in order to do
that and still tackle the other issues, he would need a unanimous consent agreement to limit debate.
According to Senate GOP aides, a unanimous consent agreement is all but certain to be a nonstarter because the bill’s
chief opponent, Sen. Tom Coburn (R-Okla.), will not agree to such a deal.
Coburn “will object and demand changes as [he has] from the get-go,” a GOP aide familiar with the situation said.
This is not the first time that Reid has run afoul of the Constitution’s tax origination provisions. His efforts to pass
a tourism promotion bill that was key to his re-election hopes was temporarily stymied earlier this year because the
Senate passed a version with revenue raisers similar to those in the food safety bill.
Spokesmen for Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.), Ways and Means Democrats and Sen. Tom Harkin (D-Iowa), a co-sponsor of
the food safety bill who authored its language, did not immediately return requests for comment. Aides for Ways and
Means Democrats also did not immediately return requests for comment.
More information about the permaculture