[cc-community] Germany - NC/CC violation - request for help

Robert Atwood lists at atwood.org.uk
Tue May 27 12:59:27 EDT 2008


Peter Brink wrote:
> Robert Atwood skrev:
>> Yuval Levy wrote:
>>
>>> yes, the SA work I did expect to be modified (and some of the people 
>>> involved did really fun stuff with it). I do expect the modifications to 
>>> be respectful of the original artwork. 
>> You may expect all you want! The license does not require that. Since 
>> the derivitive  must also  be -sa- then you could take the result and 
>> make your own derivative by stenciling 'I think this is a disrespectful 
>>   pile of crap' over it or something like that and place it in some 
>> other exhibition.
>>
> 
> The CC licenses does not affect a copyright holders moral rights. Yuval 
> is therefore quite correct when he expects respect for the artistic 
> integrity of his works.

Ok -- a valid point, and I am not very familiar with that aspect, who 
gets to decide whether it is 'respectful of the integrity' or not, if 
blanket permission for derivative works has been given already? To be 
ridiculous ... coudld I license something as cc-by-sa , but then  go 
ahead and claim for every  derivative that I discover, that it is not 
respectful, and prohibit it?

Just a thought!





> 
> /Peter Brink
> _______________________________________________
> cc-community mailing list
> cc-community at lists.ibiblio.org
> http://lists.ibiblio.org/mailman/listinfo/cc-community



More information about the cc-community mailing list